The Other Side

IMG_6278

 

Remembrance Day is tomorrow – in Canada anyway. When we moved to Germany I was surprised to discover that Germans don’t remember their war dead on November 11. Germans will take time to remember next Sunday.

Growing up as a Canadian I never thought much about the casualties on the other side. Which made a visit to Langemark Cemetery in Belgium especially moving. People died on both sides, common soldiers who had no say in the decision to go to war, but who loved their country and served with honor. This was first posted in 2014.

It is a solemn place and a stark reminder that there were no winners in the First World War. Langemark Cemetery is a memorial to young men who fought and died for a cause they believed in. But there are no rows of white headstones here. Instead the markers are black, set into the earth. The Commonwealth War Graves Commission does not tend these graves, as there are only two Allied soldiers buried here among the 44,000 dead. The brave young men who are beneath this earth were German.

The black stone markers are set in the ground, several names on each. They once were marked by crosses, but those wooden remembrances were used as firewood by the Belgians as German forces retreated during the Second World War. An understandable contempt maybe, but it would have been nice if they had bothered to keep records of whose graves were beneath those crosses before they burned them. My understanding was the grave markers are more of a best guess than a record as to who is actually buried where. There is one mass grave which holds the remains of almost 25,000 soldiers, never individually identified. The numbers are a little mind boggling.

IMG_6277

Black markers set into the ground mark the graves at Langemark German War Cemetery

In Canada the government supports the Commonwealth War Graves Commission. Each Canadian contributes through their taxes, though I suspect most are unaware of that. The German government, on the other hand, does not pay for the upkeep of the (fewer) war graves in Belgium and France. That is left to a private charity and the generosity of individual Germans.

These markers are indeed a reminder that the “enemy” was no older and no different than those fighting for the “good guys.” And indeed, here who is the enemy? As I have visited Commonwealth cemeteries I have looked for family names. Every cemetery has an Anderson or two, but it is an extremely common surname and these men are not related to me. I know I have relatives buried in Europe, my great-uncle Forrest Anderson, for example, was killed in 1918 and is buried in France at a cemetery I have never visited. There are other family surnames, but most of my relatives came home.

However there could be members of my wife’s family buried at Langemark. She is a first generation Canadian, and on the wall in the entryway, in the list of the 3,000 student-soldiers killed early in the war, I find carved one of the German family surnames. It is a possibility; we’ll have to ask her aunt, the family historian. It is only this year I discovered Vivian’s grandfather had been a solider in the First World War. I wondered at first whether my grandfather and hers had perhaps faced each other at some point in the trenches a century ago, but the only battle mentioned was Verdun, where I don’t think Canadian troops saw action. I don’t know exactly where my Grandfather fought, but one of these days I intend to look up his war record at the National Archives in Ottawa. He never spoke with me about his experiences, perhaps because of my age.

The visit to Langemark was also a reminder to me of how society can change in a short period of time. Many of the markers showed the religious affiliation of those buried there. A large number were Jewish. They served their country with pride and distinction.

That loyalty was soon forgotten. Their children would be rounded up by the government, placed on trains and shipped to death camps where they would be exterminated.

At Langemark there was no hint of that horror to come. Just the graves, and an opportunity to remember.

2 comments

  1. Been to Langemark and we were struck by the difference between that and Commonwealth War Graves locations. A completely different feeling but equally sad and reflective. Doesn’t matter what side these men fought on as it was all a tragic waste of life and should never be forgotten.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: