Too Young To Fight?

The grave of V.J. Strudwick at Essex Farm.

The grave of V.J. Strudwick at Essex Farm.

When we visited the Commonwealth Military Cemetery at Essex Farm, near Ypres, Belgium, our guide pointed out the grave of V.J. Strudwick, who was killed in action January 14, 1916 at age 15. The official age to enlist was 18, for overseas service 19.

Recruiters though generally didn`t ask probing questions, and identification documents were not all that common in those days before drivers licences, when people may not have ever even seen a car. Joe Strudwick was in all probability adult sized and willing to enlist; he said he was 19 and they either believed him or looked the other way.

It was a young man’s war, as they generally all are. With age comes maturity; older men are more likely to question the validity of a war, more likely to have family responsibilities and less likely to unquestioningly volunteer for combat. Young men romanticize war, older men know better.

Joe Strudwick was not the lone child soldier of the Great War of course. My wife Vivian’s father, who was born in 1903, signed up with the British Army in 1917. He was already 6’1” and by that point in the conflict, with millions already dead, new volunteers were much appreciated. However, his age was discovered before he reached the battlefield and he was de-mobilized. At least that is the story he told, with no paperwork to back it up, or at least none that I ever saw, I have no reason to disbelieve him.

It is estimated that perhaps as many as 250,000 child soldiers, those not old enough to officially enlist, saw combat during the First World War. Probably more than that are serving today in conflicts around the world. The nature of war has changed in the last century, becoming less formal and more open to participation by children.

The United Nations has strict rules on military service for those under 18 that all member states are expected to follow. In our less than ideal world, children become combatants in militias and brigades that are not part of any official military organization – which compounds the problem. Most parents try to protect their children, to allow them to have a happy childhood. That doesn`t always happen, as I am sure you are aware from having seen pictures of pre-teens carrying AK-47s.

I get the impression that in some ways we romanticize the child soldiers of the First World War, while being appalled at those who take up arms today. Does that have something to do with us making value judgements about the rightness of the cause? Or the difference between the organized conflict of a century ago when compared to the largely guerilla-type battles that child soldiers fight in today?

We do not know what Joe Strudwick would have grown up to be if he had been caught before being sent to the front and sent home instead of being sent to his death. The tragedy of wasted lives in war seems to be so much greater when children are involved.

Advertisements

One comment

  1. Reblogged this on From guestwriters and commented:
    Hate against some other nation or love to take revenge may bring people a long way from human sense.

    After two great wars, where so many countries were involved and so much blood was shed, still lots of people do not realise how ridiculous it is to have so much lives being offered for showing the ‘right for power’. Still today we can see that in many countries war is still romanticized and lots of people do find it an honour to have their sons going to war. Today in this world we can still find lots of child soldiers, and when it is not for the right country people find it horrible, but when it is for the ‘right country’ or ‘the right cause’ people find them heroes.
    For sure it has to do with some form of making value judgements about the rightness of the cause , by our twisted minds.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: